Skip to main content

Table 3 Overview of the prediction accuracy of the Small Dataset (242 Residues) I. The table shows the RMSD values for each of the residues from the whole dataset and the dataset following removal of non-physical values and of all outliers outside of a range of 3, 5, 7 and 10 pH units. Figures marked in bold indicate significant results (P = 0.05).

From: Benchmarking pKa prediction

 

AMBER COMPLETE

TRUE

WITHIN10

WITHIN7

WITHIN5

WITHIN3

PARSECOMPLETE

TRUE

WITHIN10

WITHIN7

WITHIN5

WITHIN3

ARG

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

ASP

2.078

1.787

2.079

2.077

1.691

1.781

3.774

1.582

2.142

1.912

1.53

1.267

CYS

*

*

*

*

*

 

*

*

*

*

*

 

GLU

1.641

1.416

1.603

1.603

1.294

1.047

3.041

1.474

1.71

1.71

1.334

1.051

HIS

2.786

1.689

1.689

1.689

1.347

1.118

2.736

1.809

1.81

1.81

1.488

1.402

LYS

1.291

1.29

1.291

1.291

1.291

1.291

1.278

1.278

1.278

1.278

1.278

1.278

TYR

2.06

1.297

1.297

1.297

1.933

0.766

2.368

1.262

1.262

1.262

1.871

0.792

 

MCCE COMPLETE

TRUE

WITHIN10

WITHIN7

WITHIN5

WITHIN3

UHBD COMPLETE

TRUE

WITHIN10

WITHIN7

WITHIN5

WITHIN3

ARG

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

ASP

1.915

1.735

1.921

1.731

1.319

1.419

0.95

0.824

0.838

0.842

0.89

0.641

CYS

*

*

*

*

*

 

*

*

*

*

*

 

GLU

1.575

1.185

1.237

1.237

1.188

0.893

0.508

0.478

0.493

0.493

0.442

0.395

HIS

1.985

1.584

1.584

1.584

1.056

1.593

0.634

0.453

0.453

0.453

0.494

0.428

LYS

1.152

1.152

1.152

1.152

1.152

1.152

0.412

0.412

0.412

0.412

0.412

0.412

TYR

6.027

1.373

1.373

1.373

1.456

1.419

0.687

0.582

0.582

0.582

0.61

0.631

 

PROPKA COMPLETE

TRUE

WITHIN10

WITHIN7

WITHIN5

WITHIN3

      

ARG

*

*

*

*

*

*

      

ASP

1.827

1.826

1.806

1.809

0.879

0.745

      

CYS

*

*

*

*

*

       

GLU

0.987

0.773

0.959

0.959

0.781

0.632

      

HIS

2.235

2.11

2.11

2.11

1.724

2.172

      

LYS

0.394

0.394

0.394

0.394

0.394

0.394

      

TYR

1.533

0.992

0.991

0.991

0.572

1.011

      
  1. Outliers
  2. COMPLETE 0 removed
  3. TRUE 25 removed
  4. WITHIN 10 11 removed
  5. WITHIN 7 13 removed
  6. WITHIN 5 34 removed
  7. WITHIN 3 54 removed